AI Deployment
[Marketing Index.]  ·  Desk 01  ·  Ads Intelligence

The auction is
automated.
The argument is not.

Original research on paid media - what the platforms report, what the business recognises, and the distance between them. Fourteen features in this edition. How we did it, the data behind it and what it does not prove.

The desk's position

The platform sees an event. The business sees an outcome.

Every paid media platform reports against the event it can observe. A click, a view, a conversion fired from a pixel it controls. That number is real, and it is not the same number the business books.

Most of what passes for paid media analysis lives inside the platform's own frame - comparing its numbers to its numbers, in its interface, against its definition of success. This desk works from the other direction: from the ledger backwards.

When the reported number and the recognised number disagree, the interesting question is not which is right. It is what the gap is made of.

We publish what we find, including where the evidence does not support a conclusion. Every feature states its method, its evidence base and what it cannot establish.

AL
The practice behind this desk

Ads Legendary

The operators who produce this research also run paid media as a service - Google, Meta and LinkedIn, inside your accounts, at 6% of media spend. Your accounts stay yours.

Features

Edition Q1 2026  ·  14 features in this desk
Feature 01  ·  Ads Intelligence

Spend rose on volume, not price

Nine of twelve major ad channels grew on volume rather than price in Q1 2026. The three exceptions are where the operating decisions actually got harder.

Read the feature →
Diverging bar chart: year-over-year unit-cost change across seventeen ad channels, Q1 2026. Reddit +71% highest, Amazon Sponsored Display −49% lowest.
Grouped bar chart: automated campaign share of platform spend across Q1 2025, Q4 2025 and Q1 2026.
Feature 02

Google's automation won. Meta's lost half its share.

Advertisers adopted automated buying, then partially reversed. The reversal is the finding.

Diverging grouped bar chart: Amazon ad formats decomposed into spend, volume and price change, Q1 2026.
Feature 03

Retail media stopped being shelf space

Retail media stopped being shelf space and became an audience business.

Diverging bar chart: CPM change by video channel, Q1 2026.
Feature 04

Digital video became television

The format converged on TV economics while still being bought as digital.

Grouped bar chart: paid click-through rate with and without an AI Overview present.
Feature 05

Paid search grew while search shrank

An answer layer sits between the query and the result. Paid search grew anyway.

Line chart: work versus non-work share of Indian ChatGPT messages over three periods.
Feature 06

The 76th-place superpower

India leads the world in AI consumption and ranks 76th on the measure that was supposed to matter.

Strategy Intelligence
Line chart: India GDP base case versus AI-enabled target, 2025 to 2035.
Feature 07

India builds the founders. It does not keep the companies.

India's AI supply side, counted properly.

Strategy Intelligence
Bar chart: China livestream commerce GMV, 2024 actual versus 2026 forecast.
Feature 08

China never had an attribution problem

A market that built commerce and media in one system never needed to solve attribution.

Line chart: number of martech products tracked, 2011 to 2026, flattening after 2024.
Feature 09

The martech market stopped growing

The stack stopped expanding. What replaced expansion is more interesting.

Bar chart: 90.3% use AI agents, 80.6% keep them in pilot, 23.3% run them in production.
Feature 10

Everyone hired the agent

Agentic tooling arrived across the industry in a single cycle.

Diverging bar chart: CPM movement across social platforms, Q1 2026. Reddit +71%, all Meta properties and Pinterest negative.
Feature 11

Cheap reach, expensive trust

Meta's CPM fell 3%. Reddit's rose 71%. Every shift in social sits between those two numbers.

Social Intelligence
Content Intelligence
Everyone cites the same number
Content Intelligence · Edition Q1 2026
Feature 12
Feature 12

Everyone cites the same number

Executive content is sold on statistics that cannot be traced to a source.

Content Intelligence
Ranked bar chart: System1 consumer Star Rating for nine named Cannes Lions 2026 Film winners against the 2.2 average of all winners.
Feature 13

Cannes winners tested badly with the public

Cannes Lions Film winners, tested with consumers. The top scored 5.9. The average was 2.2.

Stacked bar: about 6% of EU consumer app revenue left store billing; about 94% stayed inside it.
Feature 14

The app store fight moved almost no money

Two landmark rulings broke the app stores open. 3–6% of revenue moved.

Mobile Apps Intelligence
[Marketing Index.]  ·  Published quarterly

One issue a quarter.
Nothing in between.

Every edition collects the quarter's features and reports across all seven desks into a single issue. No weekly send, no roundups.

[Marketing Index.]Edition Q1 2026

The platform sees an event. The business sees an outcome.

Spend rose on volume, not price · Ads
Google's automation won. Meta's lost half its share. · Ads
Retail media stopped being shelf space · Ads
Digital video became television · Ads